![Untitled](https://i0.wp.com/www.mactalk.com.au/wp-content/uploads/2011/01/Untitled.jpg)
By Athol Hill – 7th January 2011 – Mac Apps on MacTalk
The Mac App Store went live today so I thought I’d have a look and give my perspective on this new feature in OS X.
For those who haven’t used it yet, you can enable the App Store by doing a software update. You will receive a software update that looks something like this (10.6.6) and should be around 115MB:
The update to 10.6.6 is what enables the App Store and it requires a machine restart so I’d finish off any work you’re doing before applying this udpate. Unfortunately they don’t give much more information on the app store so for those who get past this point, so look in your applications for an app called “App Store” and you’re done.
The initial screen that greets you is pretty similar to something you’d find in the iTunes App Store. It has the latest featured apps and the usual “Top Paid”, “Top Free” and “Top Grossing” Apps.
You can select business categories or use the search function if you know what you’re looking for.
Looking at the App Store, its clear in its current form that all the software vendors haven’t come on board yet. I’m not sure whether people have been slow in adding their software to the App Store or whether they just don’t want it there, but its definitely in its infancy at the moment and the store was missing some of the main software providers like Adobe and Microsoft but some of the major software suppliers like Omnigroup were there and products like Omnigraffle (Visio for Mac) are available online. I’m hoping the other vendors get on board soon because it would be great to see products like Merlin on there as well.
To test the app store, I decided to download a couple of apps to see how well the install process worked. It does require login to work but you can use your existing itunes password for this. Interestingly enough it only picked up the Apple apps that were installed and show that apps like Evernote and Text Wrangler hadn’t been installed on my machine when they were already installed but it does pick up some apps like Mindnode Pro. This is surprising given that Macupdate desktop can pick all my apps.
![](https://i0.wp.com/www.mactalk.com.au/wp-content/uploads/2011/01/Screen-shot-2011-01-07-at-9.58.51-AM.jpg)
This may not seem like a major issue, but if you want the App Store to manage updates you are going to have to re-download some of these apps via itunes. How the App Store will handle third party apps it doesn’t pick up is a mystery to me, but you may find yourself in a position where you’re still having to update some apps independently of the App Store which may be an annoyance for some people so hopefully Apple resolve this soon. The installation is pretty flawless but it does default by opening the app the moment its downloaded and inserting it in your dock which I’m not happy with. Every time I downloaded an app, I had to close it and drag it off the dock. Unfortunately there are no preferences to change this so hopefully we’ll see these appear in a future version. Purchases also only shows apps you’ve purchased through the App Store so don’t expect to see all your apps there.
![](https://i0.wp.com/www.mactalk.com.au/wp-content/uploads/2011/01/Screen-shot-2011-01-07-at-10.36.51-AM.png)
One of the interesting things I noted is that the pre-packaged products are now offered independently but no longer as a box set. I.e. Ilife or iWork. I’m not sure how the pricing would compare but I still liked the idea of buying these prepackaged. It also doesn’t offer any multi-user scenarios like the iWork edition you could install on 5 machines so this is likely to frustrate some users for the purchasing process but at least once the install is complete, the App Store will continue to handle your updates.
There is no option to remove an app from your machine so you’ll still be stuck doing this the manual way or using a product like App Zapper. (which ironically isn’t in the App Store yet)
Conclusion
Okay, so after 30 minutes of playing with the App Store here are my first impressions.
1. Its very basic and definitely a first version.
2. Not all the software vendors are on it
3. It has issues – it doesn’t pick up all the apps you have installed even if they are in the app store
4. Its missing key Apple apps like iLife as a bulk purchase option (only individual apps are offered)
5. No uninstall options
6. It can’t match existing products on the market – Macupdate Desktop is streets ahead of it for the update process.
This may seem pretty negative but Apple have a history of toning down the functionality in a package until they know they can do it properly. It does however provide some great scope for future and I’m hoping that Apple put considerable development into this product to make it work.
There are some questions I still have, like how Apple will handle things like license keys. Does it imbed a key like it does with the iPhone app store? If so, how will it handle upgrades to existing products you have? Do I have to keep copies of my old keys incase it inadvertently overwrites it? No doubt some of the less legally orientated customers will want to know what if someone downloads a pirate copy and using a pirate key? Will it simply give them an update thereby legalising their old version with a new one with an imbedded license?
Obviously its early days and there is plenty of time to answer these questions but its definitely going to be an interesting if not bumpy ride to get there.
-37.939215
145.126625
You must be logged in to post a comment.